Readwise Reader is one of the most capable reading apps available: articles, newsletters, PDFs, EPUBs and X threads in one place, with excellent highlighting and export of highlights to note-taking apps. If your goal is to read carefully and keep what you highlighted, Reader is the better tool.
Where WHT.day differs is time. Reader organises by inbox and reading status; WHT.day files every save on the day you saved it and builds timelines of any topic across your archive. Choose Reader for reading, WHT.day for keeping the record — or use both.